I made these for my husband for our first anniversary. Covers the traditional paper gift. :)
5 Gifts to Get Your Boyfriend This Christmas | Her Campus
Here are the rules I use to put inside the Open Now letter More
Ideas for the Open When... Envelopes More
What to Put Inside Open When Letters! - LDR Magazine
A Year of Dates (in a box) from The Babes Ruth. Great anniversary or wedding gift! This link includes all templates and printables.
Custom anniversary wallet card. Your choice of metal and font. Personalized to say exactly what you'd like https://www.etsy.com/listing/167203855/custom-wallet-card-insert-anniversary?ref=shop_home_active_2
2nd Anniversary gift idea for him, personalized wallet card insert. Available at https://www.etsy.com/listing/178671514/nickel-wallet-card-insert-2nd?ref=shop_home_active_15
Even though the two years has passed.. I could use this for inspiration for some other time.